
Link / Media
The budget arrives this year. The decision behind it may be twelve years old. Use Toys R Us to teach students how earlier financing choices shape marketing options, then have teams trace a budget past the person saying no to the decision that set the limit. Eight editable Google Docs, a 50-minute lesson, and a printable activity.
Somebody Else Set the Budget
In 2005, Toys R Us agreed to a leveraged acquisition. Twelve years later, its CEO told a bankruptcy court that the company’s capital structure had constrained investment in its stores.
That is a marketing problem hiding in a financing decision.
Students will probably bring up Amazon. Keep that answer on the board. This lesson asks them to go further: when a retailer needs to respond to competition, what happens if earlier commitments have already narrowed its options?
Who made the decision behind this year’s marketing budget?
What this case teaches
Marketing plans need money. But the person who hands the team a budget may be applying a loan agreement, a capital-project commitment, a funding rule, or a founder’s old preference.
This kit teaches students to find that earlier decision. They distinguish operating earnings from cash flow, examine management’s account of constrained investment, and ask what evidence would support a different allocation.
The lesson leaves room for disagreement. Competition mattered. Investment continued. Less debt would have created different options, but it would not have guaranteed a successful turnaround.
The classroom activity: Who Set This Number?
Teams get one of four fictional organizations: a restaurant chain, a public university, a hospital, or a family business.
Each has a marketing plan it cannot currently fund. Students calculate the gap and trace the limit to a decision with a date and an owner. They must identify what they know, what they are assuming, and who can change the constraint now.
The activity takes 13 minutes. It produces a one-page budget trace and one specific question to ask before accepting next year’s number.
“Finance said no” is where the investigation starts.
What’s included
Kit Overview with quick start, teaching angle, and course fit.
Complete 50-minute Lesson Plan with opening script, pacing guide, board work, and a 20-minute version.
13-slide Slides Outline with concise copy and instructor moves.
Assignment Prompt for a 500–750-word memo, with a 20-point rubric.
18 Discussion Questions across introductory, upper-level, and graduate/professional tiers.
Instructor Notes with worked answers, common objections, and course adaptations.
Three-page Student Handout with a case brief, four scenario cards, and a printable worksheet.
Source Files with academic APA references, primary case documents, and clear evidence limits.
All eight teaching documents are editable Google Docs. Make your own Google Drive copies to edit, and print the handout for class. Slides are supplied as an outline for building or adapting your own deck.
Where it fits
Use it in Principles of Marketing, Marketing Strategy, Retailing, Finance for Marketers, Strategy, Entrepreneurship, or Business and Society.
Pair it with textbook sections on strategic planning, implementation, resource allocation, and advertising or IMC budgets. The supporting readings connect marketing budgeting to financial distress, agency costs, and resources and capabilities.
Ready for a real class period
Plan on about 20 minutes of instructor preparation. Print the handout, assign one scenario per team, and teach from the pacing guide. A board and a timer are enough; slides are optional.
The case uses company filings and the CEO’s bankruptcy declaration. Historical comparisons bring in the 1980s buyout debate and Sears’s customer financing. Figures are labeled by period and measure, management estimates are attributed, and classroom scenarios are clearly fictional.
Before you argue for a bigger budget, find the decision that made it small.